There are a thousand ways to prepare a steak, but when I want to open a bottle of something amazing, I want my steak prepared simply. When I don’t have a specific wine to drink with the steak, then I might prepare it any number of ways: I might buy a flank steak and put it in a vinegary, spicy marinade or grill a porterhouse and smear Roquefort on it. When I need a steak as a compliment to a great wine, however, the goal is not to add all sorts of flavors, but to cook a great steak simply, but perfectly. Your Cab, Petite Sirah or Super Tuscan deserves a great pairing that won’t obfuscate its taste. Below are two methods. The first can be done on an impulse, the second method, and its variation, require some planning, since they are on the grill.
Standard Method:
1) Buy the highest quality steak you can splurge on. You’re going to cook it rare, so it should be great. These instructions are for grass-fed beef, by the way, which dries out a bit more easily than grain-fed. Grain-fed beef can be cooked a tiny bit hotter and/or longer.
2) Preheat your oven to 425 and put on an apron or old clothes.
3) Rub both sides of the steaks with coarse sea salt. If it is a filet mignon, rub it with highest-quality butter, too, to help keep it from drying out. Try Straus: it tastes great, it’s local, it’s sustainable and it has a high smoke point.
4) Pour a thin layer of grapeseed oil onto a skillet and turn it on high. You want the oil to get ridiculously hot. Canola oil is a decent substitute, but don’t use any other type of oil; you need a really high smoke point. DO NOT USE OLIVE OIL or you will turn everything bitter and fill your kitchen with smoke.
5) Keep your eyes on the oil and let it heat up to the point that it is just about to start smoking. It starts to get a bit “shimmery” for lack of a better word. After doing this once or twice, you’ll get it. No big deal if a wisp of smoke comes off of the oil, but you must put the steaks in immediately then.
6) Your goal is only to sear the whole steak shut. Leave the steak on for about two minutes, depending on its thickness and the heat of the pan. Flip it and leave the other side on for only one minute. Sear filet mignon for a bit less. While each side is cooking, coarsely crack some black pepper on.
7) Now put the skillet with the steaks into the oven. Again, depending on thickness, you want to put a filet mignon in for only 4 minutes and other cuts in for about 6 minutes. Let it sit for 5 minutes before serving. It still cooks during this time and this ensures that the steak stays juicy after cutting. Serve with coarsely ground pepper.
8) All these times depend on the piece of meat, how accurate your oven is and how hot your pan is. Use a meat thermometer to measure the center and get it right. Very rare is 100 degrees Farenheit, rare is 120 and medium rare is 126.
Butter-Grilled New York Strip
This method may not be too healthy, but it tastes great.
1) Drop a pound of butter into a heat-safe dish. Use more or less depending on your steaks and the size of your dish. Using your stovetop on its lowest setting or your oven on its lowest setting or any other heat source, melt the butter. You want it warm, but not warm enough to cook meat (100 degrees works well).
2) Ideally, the New York strip (also known as Delmonico or entrecote), will sit completely covered in butter, but you may have to flip them regularly if they don’t. They should be able to sit at least half-covered in butter.
3) If they are completely covered, let them sit for half an hour, if they are not fully covered by butter they may need to sit for as long as an hour. Your goal is to get them warmed up and get the butter into the steak’s grain.
4) Meanwhile get the grill going using mesquite hardwood (you can use hickory, if you like, but I prefer mesquite).
5) Sprinkle coarse sea salt on each side of each steak. Sear the steaks for about 3 minutes on each side, after the flames have died down. See above instructions for measuring doneness and serving instructions.
Variation: For a bit more flavor and doneness, take the steaks off for as brief a time as possible after searing them and cover the mesquite chips with fruitwood branches that have been soaked for half an hour in water (depending on how green they are). Good choices include grapevine trimmings, cherry branches, stone fruit trimmings (like peach and plum) and pomme fruit trimmings (like pear, quince and apple). Alternatively, you can just drop on soaked mesquite or hickory chips. If you know someone at a large winery, they may have access to oak cubes, staves or chips that have been sitting in wine or, of course, grapevine trimmings.
Close the grill and leave the steak in there for 5 to 10 minutes. This is a good technique for lesser quality meat and less special wines.
Cheers,
Gabriel Froymovich
Posted under Cooking, Food